Chinese imports drive SAF premium to lowest on record
But as it stands, Europe’s mandate is being met, but largely not with European fuel.
Black Friday is two weeks away, but sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) is already on sale. October price trends show the premium on SAF fell to its lowest monthly average on record. David Elward, SAF Lead at General Index (GX) says the premium for SAF barges in northwest Europe averaged about $1,000/t over ICE gasoil futures in October.
At its low point, SAF cost about 1.45x more than jet fuel compared with about 3.8x over a year earlier. But airlines, the largest users of SAF, typically pay a single annual SAF premium to Jet, though this depends on contract structure. So, the lower premium “doesn’t really make a blind bit of difference to the cost they are going to feel,” Elward tells SAF Investor.
The more interesting question is who is stocking the shelves. China exported about 800,000t of SAF in the first nine months of the year, almost all of it to Europe, according to Chinese customs data. China’s SAF export quota is 1.2 million tonnes which is more than Europe’s mandated SAF volumes. “China is dominating resupply into Europe,” he says. “It is effectively underpinning Europe’s mandates.”
Ample supply, much of it imported from China, helps explain why SAF premiums have collapsed. Elward says the SAF premium to ICE gasoil fell to about $880/t on October 9th. October average premiums were about $1,000/t over gasoil – the lowest month on record.
Elward says the theoretical production margin – the General Index’s SAF price against its Netherlands HEFA production-cost model – fell from close to $1,200/t in September to about $440 to $450 in October, which he links mainly to higher hydrogen and gas costs ahead of winter. “Most refiners would cut your left arm off for margins of $440 per tonne,” he adds. The decline shows how much of the earlier premium was a function of SAF’s scarcity.
Two forces shrank the premium. One is timing. S&P Global’s senior editor of EMEA Biofuels Daniel Workman tells us that the “fundamentals suggest that SAF prices should be at an absolute bottom,” because suppliers have met their 2026 SAF obligations under the ReFuelEU Aviation.
Workman says the buyers in 2025 left compliance late and bunched purchases into the third quarter. “This year has been the complete opposite,” he says, leading to an oversupplied spot market.
“The market is structurally oversupplied,” says Workman, pointing to the second force behind the shrinking premium. Europe’s mandate demand is about 800,000 to 900,000 tonnes a year, and imports of Chinese SAF are “well over that”, he says.
But this cheap SAF doesn’t really benefit airlines which burn the fuel. Customers who can use the dip in prices are voluntary buyers who want to improve their sustainability credentials. This is a good time for a private jet owner with budget left to cover some of their fuel at spot-linked prices, says Elward.
But the sheer dominance of China in fulfilling Europe’s SAF demand raises the question of what happens when supply stops. If European producers keep orienting HEFA capacity towards HVO, Elward says Europe will be “basically at the mercy” of what happens in China, which in the past has paused export quotas of refined products.
Workman says if China pauses exports of SAF, Europe could probably meet the mandate on its own. “But it’s going to be incredibly tight,” he says. Several planned projects, including from TotalEnergies, Neste, Galp, Preem and Moeve have been delayed.
But neither Workman nor Elward expect SAF supplies from China to stop suddenly. “The net effect of policymaking in Europe and in the Far East in China is that they complement each other very well right now,” Elward says. China reportedly plans to raise its export quota to 2.4 million tonnes by the end of the decade.
Moreover, Workman says the market is not convinced China is going to adopt a SAF mandate any time soon, which means more SAF for Europe. The reason, he says, is probably due to refiners earning strong margins on exports. China’s five-year plan is also likely to favour other routes such as contrail management and fleet upgrades to decarbonise aviation.
Another element is the market’s erratic behaviour. “We have seen really quite extraordinary swings in the SAF prices,” says Elward. GX data shows the premium over gasoil falling from above $2,000/t a year ago to under $1,000 in October.
He says SAF futures markets are still young, and lower liquidity generally means higher volatility. Workman adds that seasonal patterns (like the one we are seeing with premiums taking a hit in fourth quarter) are still too young to be called concrete. He anticipates a quiet final quarter of 2026, followed by a slow first quarter of 2027 and a pick-up in the third quarter.
For European policymakers, the cheap imports from China sit awkwardly beside the push for domestic production of SAF. Independent think tank Transport & Environment (T&E) said, in a briefing last week, Europe needs e-fuels that are “sustainable, scalable and sovereign”. It also warned that delays in investing in domestic production would allow competitors in the US and China to significantly “pull ahead” of Europe.
But as it stands, Europe’s mandate is being met, but largely not with European fuel.
Subscribe to our free newsletter
For more opinions from SAF Investor, subscribe to our email newsletter.
